> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://whywecanthavenicethings.info/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Japan Let Taxpayers Redirect Their Local Tax to Any Town in Return for a Thank-You Gift. A City Near Osaka Added Amazon Gift Cards, Took Nearly a Tenth of the National Total and Beat the Government in the Supreme Court.
- URL: https://whywecanthavenicethings.info/furusato-nozei-izumisano-amazon-gift-cards/
- Published: 2026-11-03T10:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-03T10:00:00.000Z
- Author: The Complaints Department
- Tags: Policy Updates

Japan's furusato nōzei, or hometown tax payment system, was introduced in 2008 under Yoshihide Suga, then the minister of internal affairs. Anyone who donates more than ¥2,000 to a prefecture or municipality of their choice can deduct everything above that ¥2,000 from their income and residence taxes, up to a limit. The idea was that city dwellers would send some of their tax back to the depopulating towns they came from, or to any place they felt grateful to. The towns thanked them with gifts, usually local produce. The scheme took off in 2015, when the deductible maximum doubled to 20 percent of the income-based portion of residence tax. By the year to March 2019, according to Nippon.com, four million taxpayers were donating a total of ¥510 billion, thirteen times the figure for 2015.

Izumisano, a city of about 100,000 in southern Osaka Prefecture, had debts of over ¥90 billion, run up largely on facilities for Kansai International Airport, and in 2009 the central government designated it a local government in need of financial improvement. Its mayor, Hiroyasu Chiyomatsu, had already tried selling the naming rights to the city and taxing dog owners. In 2014 the city signed a comprehensive deal with Trustbank Inc., which runs a hometown donation portal, and promised the company a bonus if Izumisano became number one in the country. It offered locally made towels, mileage points on the locally based budget airline Peach Aviation and, eventually, Amazon gift cards.

## The Closing-Down Sale

The ministry had been asking for restraint since April 2017, when a ministerial notice requested that return gifts be cut to 30 percent of the donation and that municipalities stop sending anything resembling cash. These were requests. In December 2018 the government's tax reform outline set the same two conditions, 30 percent and locally produced, for donations from 1 June 2019, with the minister empowered to remove municipalities that ignored them. Most towns dropped their generous offers at the end of 2018\. The town of Oyama in Shizuoka, which had been sending Amazon gift cards worth 40 percent, withdrew them. On 11 January 2019 the internal affairs minister, Masatoshi Ishida, said Oyama had exploited an institutional gap before the law changed and that he could not regard it as sensible behaviour.

Izumisano saw the same four months and drew the opposite conclusion. On 1 February 2019 it launched what it called a "closing-down campaign" on its own donation site, Sanochoku, promising to give back ¥10 billion in Amazon gift cards, worth 10 to 20 percent of each donation, on top of the ordinary return gift, as an expression of the city's gratitude. The special page featured an illustration of the deputy mayor, Hiroyuki Yashima, bowing. On 6 February Suga, by now Chief Cabinet Secretary, was asked about it at his press conference. He said hometown tax was a system for taxpayers who wanted to support their hometowns and regions that were trying hard, and asked each local government to act with good sense in line with its purpose. J-CAST News reported that Sanochoku's servers were difficult to reach for much of that day.

## The Designation

On 14 May 2019 the ministry announced which local governments could take part in the new system. All but Tokyo, which had not applied, were designated except four: Izumisano, Oyama, the town of Koya in Wakayama and the town of Miyaki in Saga. The criteria in the ministry's paperwork were specific. Each had kept offering gifts worth more than 30 percent that were not locally produced after November 2018, had added "Amazon gift cards" and similar vouchers in that period, and had used these methods, contrary to the purpose of the system, to collect more than ¥5 billion between November and March. Izumisano had collected ¥33.2 billion that way. The ministry's table gave the city's figure for the full fiscal year as ¥40.8 billion, as reported by the city, and added in a footnote that according to press reports it was ¥49.7 billion. That was nearly a tenth of the national total.

At his press conference the same morning, Ishida was asked about Izumisano's newest promotion. Knowing it was about to be excluded, the city had started a last-minute campaign, for May only, that raised its return rate to 60 percent. The minister said the ministry was in the final stage of deciding arrangements for June onwards, and that taking such action at such a time was, in the ministry's view, contrary to the purpose of the system. Chiyomatsu later told Nippon.com that about ¥17 billion of the money had been left over after paying for gifts and administration. "For a city whose annual revenues are about twenty billion yen, this is huge," he said.

## The Retroactive Part

Izumisano complained to the Central and Local Government Dispute Management Council, a body created in 2000 to stop the state overreaching in local affairs. In September 2019 the council recommended that the ministry reconsider. In October the ministry, now under Sanae Takaichi, said its decision would not change. The ministry also cut the city's special tax grants, by revising an ordinance so that donation revenue counted in the calculation. Izumisano's grants for fiscal 2019, excluding disaster funds, fell 89 percent to about ¥53 million. The Osaka High Court ruled against the city in January 2020, finding that it had "greatly impacted other municipalities by collecting donations in ways that go against the scheme's original purposes." The mayor's view was that "when our city took the initiative, they whacked us down like a whack-a-mole."

On 30 June 2020 the Supreme Court overturned the High Court. The ministry's guidelines before June 2019 had been technical advice, which local governments are not legally obliged to follow, and the Local Autonomy Act forbids the state to penalise them for ignoring it. A criterion based on how a city had raised money before the law existed exceeded what the law had delegated to the minister and was void. The court found that the Amazon gift cards could fairly be regarded as lacking the moderation expected by social norms, but that this did not show Izumisano would carry on in the same way under the new rules. Justice Keiichi Hayashi concurred, adding that he felt a certain discomfort about it: other municipalities had followed the advice while Izumisano had concentrated donations on itself. What the city had done, he wrote, was a question of propriety and not of law. Izumisano rejoined the system.

## The Points

By then most donations went through online portals, which competed for donors by awarding their own reward points. On 28 June 2024 the ministry amended its designation criteria to ban municipalities from soliciting donations through any operator that gives points on them, with effect from 1 October 2025\. Rakuten Group opposed the change immediately and started an online petition, and on 18 March 2025 its chairman, Hiroshi Mikitani, handed 2,952,819 signatures to Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba. On 10 July 2025 Rakuten sued in the Tokyo District Court to have the notice declared void. Its argument was that the Local Tax Act delegated only the method of soliciting donations to the minister, that a ban on points needed a law debated in the Diet, and that the notice therefore exceeded the minister's authority. Kentaro Hyakuno, Rakuten's vice-president, told reporters that points had become part of Japan's infrastructure. Asked about the suit, the internal affairs minister, Seiichiro Murakami, said that overheated competition over point rates was not consistent with the system's original purpose of expressing gratitude and support to municipalities that had looked after people.

Amazon Japan had entered the business in December 2024, with about 1,000 municipalities at launch, delivery of some gifts as soon as the next day, and Amazon Points worth up to 2 percent for donors who paid with the Amazon Mastercard. On 26 September 2025 the ministry revoked the designations of four municipalities, among them Miyaki, one of the four excluded in 2019\. On 9 October 2025 the Osaka High Court, under Presiding Judge Kenji Maki, upheld a lower court ruling that cutting Izumisano's special grants because of its donations had been illegal.

Donations in the year to March 2026 reached a record ¥1.33 trillion, the sixth record in a row. A ministry official said the ban on points had not reduced them. Local governments paid portal operators ¥149 billion in fees, 11.5 percent of everything donated. The largest single recipient was Izumisano, with ¥23.0 billion.

---

*Filed from public reporting:*

- [Nippon.com — "Hometown Tax Showdown: Interview with Izumisano Mayor Chiyomatsu Hiroyasu"](https://www.nippon.com/en/japan-topics/c07702/hometown-tax-showdown-interview-with-izumisano-mayor-chiyomatsu-hiroyasu.html)
- [J-CAST News — "ギフト券「100億円分」プレゼント！ 泉佐野市ふるさと納税に、菅官房長官「良識のある対応を」"](https://www.j-cast.com/2019/02/06349801.html?p=all)
- [Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications — "ふるさと納税指定制度における令和元年６月１日以降の指定等について"](https://www.soumu.go.jp/main%5Fsosiki/jichi%5Fzeisei/czaisei/czaisei%5Fseido/furusato/file/report20190514%5F02.pdf)
- [Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications — "石田総務大臣閣議後記者会見の概要(令和元年5月14日)"](https://www.soumu.go.jp/menu%5Fnews/kaiken/01koho01%5F02000803.html)
- [The Japan Times — "Dispute over hometown tax donation system"](https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2019/10/13/editorials/dispute-hometown-tax-donation-system/)
- [Nippon.com — "Japan Timeline for June 2020"](https://www.nippon.com/en/articles/-/20114)
- [Zeiri4 (税理士ドットコム) — "ふるさと納税訴訟、国はいかにして泉佐野市に敗れたか 最高裁判決を分析"](https://www.zeiri4.com/c%5F1076/n%5F944/)
- [Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications — "ふるさと納税の指定基準の見直し等"](https://www.soumu.go.jp/menu%5Fnews/s-news/01zeimu04%5F02000126.html)
- [Payment Navi — "「ふるさと納税ポイント付与禁止は営業の自由を過剰に制限」 楽天が総務省の告示無効確認を求め行政訴訟を提起"](https://paymentnavi.com/?p=163304)
- [Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications — "村上総務大臣閣議後記者会見の概要(令和7年7月15日)"](https://www.soumu.go.jp/menu%5Fnews/kaiken/01koho01%5F02001460.html)
- [Gizmodo Japan — "「Amazonふるさと納税」がスタート！ 最短翌日配送、すぐ届く"](https://www.gizmodo.jp/2024/12/amazon-furusato-tax.html)
- [Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications — "ふるさと納税の対象となる地方団体の指定の取消し"](https://www.soumu.go.jp/menu%5Fnews/s-news/01zeimu04%5F02000150.html)
- [Jiji Press (via Adnkronos) — "Japan High Court Finds State Slashing Izumisano's Grants Illegal"](https://english.adnkronos.com/2025/10/09/japan-high-court-finds-state-slashing-izumisanos-grants-illegal/)
- [Jiji Press (via Adnkronos) — "Furusato Nozei Donations Hit Another Record High in FY 2025"](https://english.adnkronos.com/2026/07/31/furusato-nozei-donations-hit-another-record-high-in-fy-2025/)