> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://whywecanthavenicethings.info/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.
- URL: https://whywecanthavenicethings.info/michigan-bottle-deposit-seinfeld/
- Published: 2026-11-09T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-09T16:00:00.000Z
- Author: The Complaints Department
- Tags: Reallocated

Michigan voters approved a bottle deposit by ballot in 1976\. At 10 cents a container it became the highest refund in the country, and the neighbouring state of Indiana has no deposit at all. The arrangement is a standing invitation, and the Associated Press reported in 2013 that smugglers were accepting it at border stores, where one store director in Niles, three miles from Indiana, said he removes people who arrive with large bags of cans.

A fraud of this kind has a famous fictional ancestor, and Michigan's real cases are routinely introduced with it. The fraud estimates belong to the industry, the state's environmental department describes the extent of fraud as unknown, and the one sum the state can measure to the dollar is the money residents leave on the counter every year without collecting it.

## The Episode

In 1996 Seinfeld aired "The Bottle Deposit," a two-part episode in which Kramer and Newman load a postal van with cans and drive for Michigan, where the deposit is 10 cents against the 5 cents in New York. The AV Club's recap has them expecting about $500 each. It also has Kramer abandoning Newman in rural Ohio to help Jerry recover a stolen car. The AP summed up the venture in a single sentence: they failed.

The episode therefore supplied a business plan and a result, and the result was failure. This has not stopped Michigan coverage of real can fraud from reaching for it.

## The Flint Case

On 22 March 2017 Attorney General Bill Schuette announced that John Custer Woodfill, 70, of Flint had pleaded guilty two days earlier in Genesee County. According to the reporting, from April 2012 to April 2015 he bought uncrushed, non-returnable cans in Indiana as scrap, through a partner, since deceased, who ran a can buying operation in Brownstown, Indiana and paid 60 to 80 cents a pound. He carried them to Michigan and redeemed them at 10 cents each. For cans the return machines would not accept he made phony labels imitating the bar code. An informant tipped off the Michigan State Police.

Schuette's office said: "This was not a one-time nickel-and-dime case." CBS headlined the plea as "Seinfeld-esque," and the Associated Press and a Patch article drew the comparison in their own voices. No report quotes Woodfill or the Attorney General mentioning the show. The comparison belongs to the newsrooms.

Sentencing, before Judge Joseph J. Farah in Genesee County, was reported on 3 May 2017\. Woodfill received three years of probation, nine months in jail held in abeyance until probation is complete, 450 hours of community service and $400,000 in restitution. He gave up his van and trailer and $4,000 of PepsiCo stock. The Attorney General's press secretary, Andrea Bitely, said: "He got so creative that he was making phony labels and barcodes."

## The Arithmetic

The case has one sum that does not balance. Patch reported that he returned "more than 10,000" containers, and Schuette's statement spoke of "tens of thousands." At 10 cents each, 10,000 containers is $1,000\. Bridge Michigan, summarising the case in 2020, said he allegedly netted $10,000 over three years. The restitution figure of $400,000 would correspond, at the same rate, to four million containers. The reports carry the numbers side by side without comment.

The same gap runs through the wider estimates. The figure usually quoted for annual fraud is $10 million to $13 million, and its source, as the AP gave it in 2013, is the Michigan Beer and Wine Wholesalers Association, using 2007 figures. Bridge wrote in 2020 that some outlets cited $10 million a year from a 2016 Detroit News opinion piece, and that the state had said the cost of fraud was unknown. In 2025 Bridge reported that the Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy still said the extent of deposit fraud was unknown. A Michigan Environmental Council policy director told Bridge in 2020 that his group had not seen numbers to suggest the fraud was so significant, and asked for an audit first.

## The Machines

Michigan did try to stop it mechanically. A 2008 law required special marks on containers sold in the state and new machines that reject out-of-state cans, with the state paying toward machine upgrades. A Treasury report estimated that the technology cut out-of-state redemptions by nearly 4 percent, though lower sales might explain part of that. In 2012 a federal appeals court in Cincinnati struck down the special-mark requirement as an illegal burden on interstate commerce. The Supreme Court denied review on 7 October 2013.

The retailer at the end of the chain was left with the machines. The AP quoted the wholesalers' association's Angela Madden saying many retailers "just refuse" to upgrade, with an upgrade costing about $5,000\. A distributor in the Upper Peninsula said it lost about $25,000 in a year on returned containers. A Representative from Coldwater proposed that attempting to return 100 to 10,000 non-returnable containers carry up to 93 days in jail and a $1,000 fine.

The law has since moved on to what stores owe consumers. Bills introduced on 5 June 2026 would require retailers to accept returns from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. or during shorter regular hours, require a "Consumer Bottle Bill of Rights" sign when machines are down, and make the Attorney General send retailers an annual written notice of their obligations. A store manager told ClickOnDetroit the nightly sorting takes at least 30 minutes.

## The Unclaimed

The deposit that goes unrefunded is the number the state has. Treasury data reported by ClickOnDetroit put the 2025 refund rate at 69.4 percent, with $389.7 million collected, $270.4 million refunded and $119.2 million not refunded. The rate was 98.2 percent in 1990\. The same data does not adjust for out-of-state containers returned for a deposit, so the state's fraud blind spot is built into the state's own statistic.

Under the law the first $1 million of the unclaimed money goes to the State Police, then 75 percent to the Cleanup and Redevelopment Trust Fund and 25 percent to retailers, who received $29.6 million. A 2020 bill would have sent part of the escheat to fraud enforcement, and the Clean Water Action write-up of it noted that no one really knows how much fraud happens and that machine returns use bar codes meant to prevent it. The Michigan Environmental Council's Conan Smith described the structure as a perverse incentive in which people benefit from the bottle bill's poor performance.

The Midwest Independent Retailers Association, which represents more than 1,000 stores, asked Governor Whitmer in February 2026 to seek repeal. In autumn 2026 its chief executive, Bill Wild, said "The bottle bill is 50 years old." The association is discussing legislation to sunset the law in two, three or five years. No bill number was given.

As of 2025 the state's environmental department described the extent of deposit fraud as unknown. The state's Treasury data lists the cost of deposits that honest residents did not bother to collect as $119.2 million.

---

*Filed from public reporting:*

- [CBS News — "Michigan man guilty in 'Seinfeld'-esque can return scheme"](https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/michigan-man-guilty-in-seinfeld-esque-can-return-scheme)
- [Patch — "Seinfeld Michigan Can Deposit Scam Ends in Plea"](https://patch.com/michigan/detroit/seinfeld-michigan-can-deposit-scam-ends-plea)
- [Patch — "Pop Can Scam Man Gets 3 Years Probation"](https://patch.com/michigan/detroit/pop-can-scam-man-gets-3-years-probation)
- [WCMU — "Man sentenced in $400,000 pop can scam"](https://www.wcmu.org/local-regional-news/2017-05-04/man-sentenced-in-400-000-pop-can-scam)
- [Associated Press via Fox News — "Smugglers still cashing in on Michigan can refund"](https://www.foxnews.com/politics/smugglers-still-cashing-in-on-michigan-can-refund)
- [The A.V. Club — "Seinfeld: The Bottle Deposit"](https://www.avclub.com/seinfeld-the-bottle-deposit-1798169997)
- [SCOTUSblog — "Snyder v. American Beverage Association"](https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/case-files/snyder-v-american-beverage-association)
- [Bridge Michigan — "Michigan businesses want to cut millions in uncollected pop returnables"](https://bridgemi.com/michigan-environment-watch/michigan-businesses-want-cut-millions-uncollected-pop-returnables/)
- [Bridge Michigan — "Michigan's bottle return rates keep falling. Is it time for change?"](https://bridgemi.com/michigan-environment-watch/michigans-bottle-return-rates-keep-falling-it-time-change/)
- [Clean Water Action — "$8 million: Stop Kramer and Newman"](https://cleanwater.org/2020/02/18/8-million-stop-kramer-and-newman)
- [ClickOnDetroit — "Michigan bottle refund rate falls to 69.4% as retailers push to overhaul bottle bill"](https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/local/2026/09/28/michigan-bottle-return-rate-falls-to-694-percent-as-retailers-push-to-overhaul-bottle-bill/)
- [ClickOnDetroit — "Michigan's bottle deposit refund rate falls to lowest level in decades"](https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/local/2026/10/03/michigans-bottle-deposit-refund-rate-falls-to-lowest-level-in-decades-should-the-law-be-scrapped/)
- [Resource Recycling — "Three-bill package aims to revamp Michigan's bottle return system"](https://resource-recycling.com/recycling/2026/06/09/three-bill-package-aims-to-revamp-michigans-bottle-return-system/)
- [The Alpena News — "Michigan's independent retailers urge Whitmer to seek repeal of the Bottle Bill"](https://www.thealpenanews.com/news/2026/02/michigans-independent-retailers-urge-whitmer-to-seek-repeal-of-the-bottle-bill)