US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.
The Department of Transportation added a provision dedicated to service animals on aircraft in 2008, codifying earlier guidance. Emotional support animals and psychiatric service animals counted as service animals, and airlines may not charge for service animals. Airlines were in turn allowed to require a letter from a licensed mental health professional stating the passenger's need, and 48 hours' notice so that someone could read it. The Federal Register later put the economics in one sentence: because airlines charge for pets and may not charge for service animals, "passengers previously had an incentive to claim their pets were ESAs."
The letters were available online. American Airlines told the Department that an "increase in the availability of fraudulent ESA credentials" had enabled people to "abuse the rules and evade airline policies regarding animals in the cabin." Open Doors Organization told it that airlines could show letters resulting from fee-based online evaluations with "minimal therapeutic interaction" between professional and traveler. In January 2016 a Delta passenger flew with a turkey in its own seat. Delta told USA Today, as Fox News reported, that its employees "made a judgment call based in part on extensive documentation from the customer."
The Menagerie
The turkey became public as a photograph. A Reddit user posted it and said a neighbour who was a flight attendant had taken it, and a second user posted another of the bird being wheeled through the airport in a wheelchair. Delta said it had complied with the Air Carrier Access Act. In November 2014 a pig brought aboard a US Airways flight at Bradley International Airport in Connecticut as an emotional support animal was ordered off after the crew judged it disruptive. A passenger estimated it at 50 to 70 pounds and said it walked back and forth on its leash. A US Airways spokeswoman said federal rules permitted such animals unless they were disruptive.
In October 2016 a duck named Daniel flew from Charlotte to Asheville on American Airlines, wearing red shoes and a Captain America diaper. His owner, Carla Fitzgerald of Wisconsin, said she has post-traumatic stress disorder and had given the airline a note from her doctor. The crew issued Daniel a Certificate of First Flight, which was a souvenir.
The Peacock
On Sunday 28 January 2018 a Brooklyn performance artist who goes by Ventiko arrived at Newark Liberty International Airport with a peacock named Dexter, bound for Los Angeles on United. She had bought him a ticket so that he would have his own seat. United refused to board him. Its spokeswoman, Andrea Hiller, told the Associated Press that the bird did not meet guidelines for several reasons, including size and weight, and that the issues had been explained to the passenger three times before she arrived at the airport.
The record therefore differs from the legend. Dexter never flew. A United spokesman, Charlie Hobart, said the old policy had worked as intended, since it kept Dexter off the plane, and that the incident "had absolutely nothing to do with" new measures taking effect on 1 March 2018. Those required 48 hours' notice, a letter from a mental health professional, confirmation of the animal's training and a veterinarian's record. United said: "Year over year, we have seen a 75 percent increase in customers bringing emotional support animals on board." Fox News, citing USA Today, reported 43,000 animals in 2016 and 76,000 in 2017.
The Dog
Delta announced its own tightening in January 2018, also effective 1 March, and gave its reasons in numbers. Its releases said it carried about 700 service or support animals a day, nearly or more than 250,000 a year, up nearly 150 percent since 2015. They cited an "84 percent increase in reported incidents involving service and support animals since 2016," including urination, defecation, biting and a widely reported attack by a 70-pound dog. Fortune reported that Delta had also been asked to carry "comfort turkeys, gliding possums known as sugar gliders, snakes, spiders and more." John Laughter, Delta's senior vice president for corporate safety, security and compliance, said the rise in serious incidents had led the airline to its changes.
The attack was on a flight from Atlanta to San Diego in June 2017. In May 2019 the passenger in the window seat, Marlin Jackson, sued Delta and the dog's owner in Fulton County, Georgia. NBC News reported that he needed 28 stitches, lost sensation in parts of his face and bled heavily enough that the row of seats had to be removed from the aircraft. The suit alleges that Delta's policy required large emotional support dogs to be secured on the floor, and that the dog was allowed to stay in its owner's lap. Those are allegations. Delta said it could not comment on pending litigation. NBC, citing the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, gave the dog's weight as 50 pounds, where Delta's releases said 70. The reporting does not say how the case ended.
The Rule
The Department announced its final rule on 2 December 2020. That day a Delta spokeswoman told the Associated Press: "At this time, there are no changes to Delta's current service and support animal policies." The rule was published on 10 December and took effect on 11 January 2021. It defines a service animal as "a dog, regardless of breed or type, that is individually trained to do work or perform tasks for the benefit of a qualified individual with a disability." Carriers "are not required to recognize emotional support animals as service animals and may treat them as pets."
The Department gave five reasons: rising complaints, inconsistent federal definitions, disruptions from requests to carry unusual species, travelers fraudulently representing pets as service animals, and reported misbehavior by emotional support animals. The unusual species, it said, had "eroded the public trust in legitimate service animals." It found persuasive the information that emotional support animals, or animals presented as such, "are responsible for a significant percentage of the incidents of animal misbehavior onboard aircraft." Its economic analysis described the old arrangement as "a price restriction that sets the price of accommodating passengers who travel with ESAs at zero dollars." The rule text does not contain the word peacock.
The airlines moved at once. According to CNN, Delta, United, Alaska and JetBlue stopped accepting new emotional support animal reservations on 11 January 2021, and American honored existing bookings only through the end of the month. On 25 January Southwest announced it would stop carrying them from 1 March. Steve Goldberg, its senior vice president of operations and hospitality, said: "We applaud the Department of Transportation's recent ruling that allows us to make these important changes."
The Ledger
Of about 15,000 comments on the proposal, more than 10,000 concerned emotional support animals. More than 3,000 supported the change, as did a large majority of airline-industry organizations and about half of the disability rights groups that commented, mainly those representing people with allergies and guide dog users. More than 6,000 commenters opposed it. The Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund told the Department that an emotional support animal is frequently the primary intervention enabling a person with a psychiatric disability to succeed at daily activities, "and sometimes to stay alive." A joint comment led by Paralyzed Veterans of America noted that pet fees could cost upwards of $175 each way, and that people with disabilities are disproportionately low income.
The Department tabulated the result in 2018 dollars. Airlines would save $15.6 million to $21.6 million a year. Passengers who kept traveling with their animals would pay airlines $54.0 million to $59.6 million in additional fees. The lost benefits to individuals who no longer travel with emotional support animals were put at $7.8 million to $10.6 million a year. The reduction in negative externalities caused by the animals was listed as "Not quantified." The rule also lets airlines require service animal users to submit Department forms, which the Department estimated at 74,000 burden hours and $1.1 million a year. Psychiatric service dogs remain covered and need no letter. To the objection that an emotional support rabbit cannot be trained to perform a task, the Department replied that most emotional support animals are dogs, and that service animal users "are free to train their own dogs."
A peacock was refused boarding in January 2018 under the rules then in force. The rule that abolished the category was finalized in December 2020 with the support of the airlines, and it came with an itemized estimate of what the change would cost the people who had needed it.
Filed from public reporting:
- Federal Register (via GovInfo) — "Traveling by Air With Service Animals," 85 FR 79742, 10 December 2020
- CBS News (AP) — "Woman denied emotional support peacock on United flight"
- Fox News — "Unbelievable: Emotional support peacock denied on United flight"
- Fortune — "Delta Emotional Support Animals," 19 January 2018
- Delta — "Updated Requirements Begin for Customers Traveling with Service or Support Animals"
- Delta — "Delta service and support animal policy effective March 1, enhancements added"
- NBC News — "Man attacked by emotional-support dog on Delta flight sues the airline and passenger"
- Fox News — "Flying turkey ruffles feathers about emotional support animals on planes"
- Fox News — "US Airways says pig not allowed to fly after becoming disruptive"
- Anchorage Daily News — "Daniel the emotional support duck takes his first plane ride, soars in popularity"
- FOX 29 (AP) — "No more emotional support animals on planes after DOT closes major loophole"
- KRDO (CNN Newsource) — "Southwest joins other airlines in banning emotional support animals"