The Man Who Wrote the Password Rules Said in 2017 That He Regretted Them. His Own Guideline Had Predicted in 2004 That Everyone Would Capitalize the First Letter and Put the Symbol at the End.

Share
The Man Who Wrote the Password Rules Said in 2017 That He Regretted Them. His Own Guideline Had Predicted in 2004 That Everyone Would Capitalize the First Letter and Put the Symbol at the End.
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya / Unsplash

In June 2004 the National Institute of Standards and Technology published Special Publication 800-63, the Electronic Authentication Guideline, by William Burr, Donna Dodson and Timothy Polk. It was written for US federal agencies. Its Appendix A set out a method for estimating how strong a password was, and it awarded a bonus of six bits of entropy to any system that required users to include both upper case and non-alphabetic characters.

The method had no password data behind it. The authors said so. They started from Claude Shannon's estimates of the entropy of ordinary English text, noted that it would be better to have a large body of real passwords to work from but that "we have no such resource", and warned readers not to treat the rules "as anything more than a very rough rule of thumb". Login pages, email systems and online banking adopted them anyway, and not as a rough rule of thumb.

The Paragraph in the Middle

Between the caveat and the bonus, the same appendix described what would happen. It assumed that rules forcing capital letters or non-alphabetic characters "will generally be satisfied in the simplest and most predictable manner, often by putting a capital letter at the start (as we do in ordinary English) and punctuation or special characters at the end, or by some simple substitution, such as $ for the letter 's.'" It added that rules making passwords look highly random would be "counterproductive", because users would write them down.

The composition rule then got its six bits. The appendix admitted the benefit was "probably modest". What spread was the rule. The paragraph predicting how people would satisfy it stayed on page 48.

The Expiry Date

Forced rotation came along with it. The 2004 text did not ask for it. Its worked examples imagined passwords changed every two years, or every ten. Organisations settled on something much shorter. Microsoft's own Windows security baseline recommended 90 days, and later 60. At the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, the single sign-on password had to be changed every three months, on pain of suspension, and had to include a letter, a digit and a special character.

In 2010, three UNC computer scientists, Yinqian Zhang, Fabian Monrose and Michael Reiter, obtained 51,141 old password hashes from 10,374 closed accounts and studied how people replaced expired passwords. Capitalising one letter was common, as in "17candy#" becoming "17candY#". So was adding a digit, as in "dance#7" becoming "dance#78". Given one old password, their algorithm broke the next one for about 41 percent of accounts, in under three seconds each. For 17 percent, it took fewer than five online guesses. The paper's own conclusion was that it "calls into question the merit of continuing the practice of password expiration."

In October 2016 the UK's National Cyber Security Centre explained why its 2015 guidance had advised against regular expiry. When forced to change a password, "the chances are that the new password will be similar to the old one," and attackers "can often work out the new password, if they have the old one."

The Regret

In June 2017 NIST published SP 800-63B, a full rewrite. Verifiers "SHOULD NOT impose other composition rules", and "SHOULD NOT require memorized secrets to be changed arbitrarily (e.g., periodically)." Its appendix noted that users respond to composition rules "in very predictable ways". A user who would have chosen "password" becomes "Password1". William Burr is among the twelve authors listed on it.

In August 2017 Burr, by then retired, told the Wall Street Journal: "Much of what I did I now regret." The guidance, he said, "was barking up the wrong tree." Coverage of the interview reported that his research had come mostly from a white paper written in the 1980s.

The Requirement

In May 2019 Microsoft took password expiration out of its security baseline, calling it "an ancient and obsolete mitigation of very low value." The explanation was brief: "If a password is never stolen, there's no need to expire it." In the same post, Microsoft said it was not proposing any change to its requirements for password complexity.

NIST's fourth revision, SP 800-63B-4, was published on 31 July 2025. The recommendations became requirements: verifiers "SHALL NOT impose other composition rules" and "SHALL NOT require subscribers to change passwords periodically." A password used as the only authentication factor must now be at least 15 characters long. NIST also requires new passwords to be checked against a list of known, common and compromised passwords. That is the empirical approach the 2004 authors wished they had the data for.

The guideline was right about two things: how people would satisfy its rules, and that the rules were only a very rough rule of thumb. Neither was the part anyone adopted. Twenty-one years after publication, the rules are forbidden in federal systems, and the paragraph that predicted why is still on page 48.


Filed from public reporting:

Read more

Disney's Guest Assistance Card Gave Guests Who Could Not Wait in Line Faster Access With No Proof of Disability Required. Its Replacement Now Requires a Video Interview, and Disney's Own Court Papers Put Holders at 20 Percent of Guests.

Disney's Guest Assistance Card Gave Guests Who Could Not Wait in Line Faster Access With No Proof of Disability Required. Its Replacement Now Requires a Video Interview, and Disney's Own Court Papers Put Holders at 20 Percent of Guests.

Disney's Guest Assistance Card was, in Disney's later description, an accommodation that asked for nothing. A guest who could not wait in a conventional queue went to Guest Relations, said so, and received a card that opened a side entrance or a shorter line. NBC reported

By The Complaints Department
Westvleteren Abbey Sells Its Trappist Beer Only to Private Buyers Who Agree Not to Resell It. A Dutch Supermarket Put 7,200 Bottles on Its Shelves at 9.95 Euros Each Anyway.

Westvleteren Abbey Sells Its Trappist Beer Only to Private Buyers Who Agree Not to Resell It. A Dutch Supermarket Put 7,200 Bottles on Its Shelves at 9.95 Euros Each Anyway.

The Sint-Sixtus Abbey in Westvleteren, West Flanders, brews three Trappist beers and sells them to one kind of customer: the private individual. The abbey's own conditions of sale, which every buyer accepts, contain a clause of a single sentence, in which the buyer undertakes not to resell

By The Complaints Department
Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.

Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.

Michigan voters approved a bottle deposit by ballot in 1976. At 10 cents a container it became the highest refund in the country, and the neighbouring state of Indiana has no deposit at all. The arrangement is a standing invitation, and the Associated Press reported in 2013 that smugglers were

By The Complaints Department
US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.

US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.

The Department of Transportation added a provision dedicated to service animals on aircraft in 2008, codifying earlier guidance. Emotional support animals and psychiatric service animals counted as service animals, and airlines may not charge for service animals. Airlines were in turn allowed to require a letter from a licensed mental

By The Complaints Department