The British Museum Found About 2,000 Items Stolen, Damaged or Missing, Many From Stock It Had Never Registered. A Dealer Had Warned It in 2021, and Its Reply Was That the Objects Were All Accounted For.
In August 2023 the British Museum announced that items had been stolen from its collection and that a member of staff had been dismissed. The Museums Association reported the details as they stood on 17 August: the missing, stolen or damaged pieces were mostly small objects from one storeroom, gold jewellery and gems of semi-precious stone and glass dating from the 15th century BC to the 19th century AD. None had recently been on display. They were kept mainly for academic and research use, which is a polite way of saying that nobody was looking at them.
The figure that eventually settled was about 2,000 items identified as damaged or missing, of which about 1,500 were stolen or missing, according to the Museums Association's account of the independent review. Unregistered items were a key target. A collection that is not catalogued cannot be audited, and a collection that cannot be audited runs on the honesty of whoever holds the key. The museum had, until then, been using the second system.
The Warning
Ittai Gradel was a Denmark-based dealer in ancient gems. According to correspondence seen by The New York Times and summarised by Art Daily, he contacted the museum in 2021 with evidence that three gems from its collection had been offered for sale on eBay. He wrote that the thief must be an insider and that the three gems were "only the tip of a much larger iceberg."
Jonathan Williams, a deputy director, replied that the objects were "all accounted for" and that there was no sign of wrongdoing by staff. In October 2022, the same report says, the director, Hartwig Fischer, told a trustee that the matter was closed. The museum's own investigation in 2021 and 2022 had concluded that nothing untoward had happened. In 2023 a spokesperson declined to comment on that investigation, saying "we can't comment further at this point" while the reviews were ongoing.
Fischer was later more forthcoming. Hyperallergic quotes him saying that the museum "did not respond as comprehensively as it should have in response to the warnings in 2021." He left in August 2023, and The Art Newspaper recorded that Williams also departed. Gradel, who had bought 351 of the stolen pieces without realising they were stolen, returned them to the museum. According to Cultural Property News, 350 of the 356 items returned by early 2024 came from him. He was the museum's principal source of recovered property, and for a time its principal source of unwelcome correspondence.
The Review
The independent review was led by Nigel Boardman, a solicitor and British Museum trustee, with Lucy D'Orsi, a chief constable, and Ian Karet, a deputy High Court judge. Only four of its 30 pages were made public, for security reasons. The Museums Association reported in December 2023 that it found unregistered items, mainly gems and jewellery in the Department of Greece and Rome, to have been a key target. It recommended closing gaps in registration and documentation, strengthening audit, risk, governance and security, and reviewing how the museum suspends employees.
The museum accepted the recommendations and said it planned to finish documenting and digitising the whole collection within five years, aiming to "eliminate any pockets of unregistered objects." The chair, George Osborne, said the museum had commissioned the review "because we were determined to learn the lessons of what went wrong."
The review also gave the damage a taxonomy. About 350 items had portions removed, such as gold mounts, and most are likely unrecoverable. About 140 were damaged by tool marks. The Museums Association further reported that the alleged thief reportedly took around £100,000 over 30 years, and that some items had reportedly sold on eBay for about £50.
The Claim
The Art Newspaper reported that Peter Higgs, then acting head of the Greece and Rome department, was dismissed for gross misconduct in July 2023, and that in December 2023 the trustees decided to pursue civil litigation against him. In March 2024 the museum brought a claim in the High Court. Higgs denies wrongdoing, and no report says he has been charged with any offence. What follows is the museum's case, as summarised by Cultural Property News from its filed claim. None of it has been tested in court.
The museum alleges that the thefts began as early as 2009 and involved more than 1,800 seals, cameos, jewellery and small gold and silver items. It alleges that Higgs sold items on eBay and PayPal under false names, including "Sultan1966" and "Paul Higgins." It says museum records show at least 24 entries into the strongroom between 2014 and 2023, and that Higgs has accepted he was sometimes alone there. It says 83 of 98 edits made through his computer account related to items later found damaged or stolen. Of 1,449 unregistered items inventoried in one strongroom, the museum says 1,161 were missing.
At the March 2024 hearing the museum's lawyer, Daniel Burgess, said that Higgs had tried to conceal his actions, including by using false names, creating false documents and manipulating museum IT records. The Globe and Mail reported that Higgs filed a defence stating that he intends to dispute the civil claim, and that Justice Heather Williams ordered him to provide a list of items he is suspected of taking and to return any still in his possession. His son told The Times, as reported by the Brown Art Review, that his father "hadn't done anything wrong."
The Recovery
In May 2024 the museum announced 268 more recovered objects, bringing the total returned to 626, of which The Art Newspaper counted 351 from Gradel and 268 from other sources. The museum said it was pursuing new leads on around 100 more. The Art Newspaper put the number still missing at about 874, while noting that its introduction said "more than 800." Osborne said at the time: "Few expected to see this day, and even I had my doubts."
The recovered pieces came from across Europe and North America. The museum was therefore in the position of having collected, from the open market, a large part of what its own storeroom had failed to count.
The Status
The Metropolitan Police search of Higgs's home in August 2023 seized 11 electronic devices, according to the Brown Art Review, which reported in October 2024 that a multi-jurisdiction police investigation was ongoing and that he had not been charged. Gradel died in April 2026, aged 61. Jewish News reported on 28 April that the Met investigation remained ongoing, with developments reportedly expected in the coming months, and that Gradel had given evidence to police. It added that the museum had given him a rarely presented medal, and that its director, Nicholas Cullinan, had praised his "very significant contribution."
No report of a charge, a trial or a judgment in the civil claim could be found as of November 2026.
The museum has spent three years and an independent panel establishing that about 2,000 objects were stolen, damaged or missing. The review that established it runs to 30 pages, and the public may read four of them.
Filed from public reporting:
- Museums Association — "British Museum investigating thefts from its collections"
- Museums Association — "Review urges tighter security and documentation at British Museum"
- Art Daily — "British Museum was warned gems were being sold on eBay, emails show"
- Hyperallergic — "British Museum Sues Former Curator Over Alleged Thefts"
- Cultural Property News — "Dirty Details: British Museum Presses Case Against Former Curator Peter Higgs"
- The Globe and Mail — "British Museum obtains court order against ex-curator over alleged thefts"
- The Art Newspaper — "British Museum recovers a further 268 stolen objects"
- Brown Art Review — "Higgs Hits the Stand"
- Jewish News — "Jewish antiquities dealer who exposed British Museum theft scandal dies aged 61"