Sears Promised to Replace Any Broken Craftsman Hand Tool at Any Sears Store, No Receipt Required. Craftsman Now Says to Return Products to the Original Place of Purchase, and by November 2025 Sears Had Five Stores.
Sears registered the Craftsman trademark in 1927, and the hand tools came with a warranty one sentence long. In the version a Sears vice president quoted in 2009, it read: "If for any reason your Craftsman hand tool ever fails to provide complete satisfaction, return it to any Sears store or other Craftsman outlet in the United States for free repair or replacement." It said nothing about receipts, original owners, the age of the tool or the state it arrived in. A broken wrench went on the counter and a new one came back, or, as Yahoo Finance put it, sometimes a rebuilt one "with someone else's initials still scratched in."
The warranty attached to the tool, not to the person holding it, and the tools outlived their owners. Yahoo Finance recorded the legend that scavengers combed the trash for old, broken Craftsman wrenches made half a century earlier, swapped them at Sears and sold the new ones. "We used to have people go looking for Craftsman tools at old garage sales," one former employee wrote on Reddit, "or from little old ladies who still had some in storage and return them for brand new [tools], then turn around and sell them as new." In March 2007 a writer for Consumerist mentioned in passing a neighbour who haunted garage sales for rusty Craftsman tools to exchange at Sears, and had never once been refused.
The Rust
That month a Consumerist reader called Rufus wrote in from New Orleans. He had taken rusty sockets and socket drivers back to Sears after Hurricane Katrina under what he called, in capitals, the FULL UNLIMITED WARRANTY, and was told the store was not accepting any rusty tools. A display of injured feelings got one socket driver exchanged. The rest stayed rusty.
Consumerist's Ben Popken asked Sears for the policy. The reply, from a customer care agent signing himself Rod N., described a lifetime warranty "against product defects" and then listed exclusions that included "but is not limited to" alteration, theft, acts of God such as fire and flood, use for anything other than the intended purpose, "including neglect," precision tools with mechanisms, and "Rust that does not prohibits the performance of the item." Popken concluded that rust which actually stopped a tool working would still count, and signed off: "Consider our outrage retracted." He also observed that it was "just not right" to advertise a full and unlimited lifetime warranty with some restrictions applying.
The Sockets
In March 2009 Consumerist ran a four-part saga about a reader called Brian, an IT professional who had moved from Huntsville, Alabama, to San Antonio, Texas. He owned more than 1,000 Craftsman pieces, had inherited his grandfather's set, and kept a separate box for broken ones. The U-Haul leaked on the way, and the box rusted along with everything else. He cleaned what he could and took nine rounded 12-point sockets, a screwdriver with a broken tip and a pair of vice grips that would no longer grip to his nearest Sears.
The Tool Associate told him that sockets were not replaced because of rust, that customers could exchange only three tools a day, and that it was "obvious" he "didn't take care of them." Brian left with the screwdriver and the vice grips. Above the store entrance, he noted, large letters read "Satisfaction Guaranteed or your Money Back!" A phone agent told him to throw the sockets away. A second, Judy, told him that rust excluded every tool, that the warranty was not transferable, and explained the reason: customers "were buying Craftsman tools at flea markets and returning them for new ones, which isn't allowed." Brian then found an email from a Sears representative in 2005 stating that "The guarantee is not limited to the original owner."
A Sears email then told him to clean the rust off and try again. He did, and went back dressed more smartly. A different associate, Bill, exchanged five of the nine sockets without comment, despite rust remaining on the inside, and did not mention a daily limit. "There are a lot of factors to consider," Brian wrote: "I was dressed nicer, I got a different associate named Bill, I had cleaned off some rust, they were busy, or it could have been a corporate memo defining 'Lifetime'."
The Memo
There was a memo. On 25 March 2009 Consumerist published an apology from David Figler, a Sears Holdings vice president, with an excerpt of the memo he had sent the stores. It cited complaints of denied exchanges for "Tools having rust on them" and "A 3 Piece per day limit on exchanges," and declared: "These are NOT valid reasons for denying our customers their right to exchange their Craftsman Tools under the Lifetime Warranty." The warranty, it said, was "one of the most important competitive advantages we have in the market." Figler's covering note promised "complete satisfaction – period."
The period lasted until 2014. Sears's warranty from that year, as quoted by Yahoo Finance in 2017 and reprinted in full by ToolGuyd in 2019, still promised that a hand tool that "ever fails to provide complete satisfaction" would be repaired or replaced free of charge. To obtain it, however, the customer now had to return the product "to the Sears Brands Management Corporation authorized retailer from which it was purchased." Coverage would follow "the retailer warranty exchange procedure and may be subject to a limitation on the number of items allowed per exchange." The daily limit that headquarters had disowned in 2009 had become a clause, and the flea-market wrench, which had been purchased somewhere by someone, now needed to know where.
The Sale
On 5 January 2017 Sears Holdings, closing stores and short of cash, announced the sale of Craftsman to Stanley Black & Decker. The deal closed on 9 March: $525 million at closing, $250 million at the end of year three, and royalties of 2.5 to 3.5 per cent on Stanley's new Craftsman sales for 15 years, about $900 million in all. Sears kept the right to sell Craftsman in its own stores. James Loree, Stanley's chief executive, said the company understood "the Craftsman warranty is important to existing customers" and intended "to honor existing and offer similar warranties going forward." Stanley's own hand-tool warranty, published in 2019, read: "If the product fails to perform for any reason, we will replace it. Return damaged product to a stocking Retail Partner." It added: "No proof of purchase required."
The stocking retail partner was mainly Lowe's. Gary Galloway, who works on old cars and whose local Sears had closed, took a broken socket wrench to his local Lowe's and was told, he said, that Lowe's "could not replace any tool that was not sold at the Lowe's store." The Sears tools and the Lowe's tools had different part numbers. Maureen Wallace of Lowe's corporate communications told the Scripps consumer reporter John Matarese that Lowe's would honour all lifetime warranties "no matter where the CRAFTSMAN hand tool was purchased," and would "replace it if we have the product." If not, customers could call a customer care hotline. Craftsman's number begins 888.
Sears, meanwhile, emerged from bankruptcy in February 2019 under its former chairman Eddie Lampert as Transform Holdco and launched a "Craftsman Ultimate Collection" of mechanics' tools. Peter Boutros, its chief brand officer, announced: "Sears is the real home of the broadest assortment of Craftsman." Stanley sued in Manhattan federal court on 6 March 2019, complaining that the tagline implied Craftsman products sold elsewhere were "somehow illegitimate." The case was dismissed on 15 April with undisclosed terms. As of 15 May, HBSDealer reported, the press release was still on the Sears Holdings website.
The Counter
The warranty had always depended on the counter more than on the wording, and the counters went first. Sears and Kmart had about 3,500 stores between them when Lampert merged them in 2005. The company that left bankruptcy in 2019 had 223 Sears stores. By December 2024 Sears operated in four states. In November 2025 CNN counted five stores, in Braintree, Massachusetts; Concord, California; El Paso, Texas; Orlando, Florida; and Coral Gables, Florida, where the site could become 1,000 homes. Mark Cohen, a former Sears Canada executive, said customers "didn't stop buying circular saws or screwdrivers and hammers," and that what was left was "phantoms in the night."
Craftsman's warranty page now opens with a single instruction for any product needing replacement under warranty: "simply return the product to the original place of purchase." For most of a century the original place of purchase was Sears, which had accepted Craftsman tools from any decade, any owner and any garage sale. In November 2025 it was five stores.
Filed from public reporting:
- Yahoo Finance — "Craftsman's famous lifetime warranty in question after $900 million sale"
- Consumerist — "The Softer Side Of Sears: Craftsman Lifetime Warranty Doesn't Apply To Katrina Victims"
- Consumerist — "Clarification: Craftsman Lifetime Warranty Doesn't Apply To Rusty Tools"
- Consumerist — "Craftsman's "Lifetime Warranty" Depends On Tool Associate's Mood"
- Consumerist — "Sears Can't Get Its Story Straight Regarding Rust And Craftsman Tools"
- Consumerist — "Brian Manages To Replace His Rusty Craftsman Sockets At Sears"
- Consumerist — "Sears Clarifies Craftsman Tools Warranty"
- ToolGuyd — "Craftsman Hand Tools Warranty Information Update"
- Vehicle Service Pros — "Stanley Black & Decker completes purchase of Craftsman brand from Sears Holdings"
- WPTV / Scripps — "Will Lowe's stores honor Craftsman 'lifetime' warranties?"
- CNBC — "Sears is sued over 'Craftsman' brand"
- HBSDealer — "Craftsman case dismissed"
- CNN Newsource via WOWT — "Sears now only operating stores in 4 states after most recent closure"
- CNN via KVIA — "Could this finally be Sears' last Black Friday?"
- Craftsman — "Warranty Information"