Mexico City Took Every Private Car Off the Road One Weekday a Week From 1989 to Clean Its Air. Drivers Bought Second Cars With Different Plates, Mostly Old Ones, and the Air Showed No Measurable Improvement.

Share
Mexico City Took Every Private Car Off the Road One Weekday a Week From 1989 to Clean Its Air. Drivers Bought Second Cars With Different Plates, Mostly Old Ones, and the Air Showed No Measurable Improvement.
Photo by Bhargava Marripati / Unsplash

On 20 November 1989, with ozone at record levels, the government of Mexico City introduced Hoy No Circula, "today it does not circulate." The rule was simple and needed no new infrastructure. Every private car was banned from the road one weekday a week, from 5 a.m. to 10 p.m., according to the last digit of its licence plate: plates ending in 5 or 6 stayed home on Mondays, 7 or 8 on Tuesdays, and so on. Taxis, buses, ambulances and lorries carrying perishable goods were exempt. The ban covered the whole metropolitan area and 2.3 million vehicles, which meant 460,000 cars off the road every weekday. Offenders had their cars impounded for 48 hours and paid a fine. La Jornada's headlines that first week, as later catalogued by the economist Lucas Davis, included "Ocho mil vehículos detenidos en la primera jornada" and "Espera recaudar el DDF, 710 mil millones en una semana."

It was meant to be temporary, a measure for the winter months when thermal inversions trap the valley's air. In October 1990 the head of the city government, Manuel Camacho Solís, announced that it would continue. He had already told a United Nations meeting in New York on 3 September that Hoy No Circula was part of a 28-point programme that had cut contaminants by 23 percent that year. Ramón Ojeda, the city's director of pollution prevention, told The Christian Science Monitor that 80 percent of the public supported it. "But if support drops below 60 percent we won't continue," he said. Ivan Restrepo, director of the Center for Ecodevelopment, had a different set of numbers. "Gasoline sales are up and 175,000 new cars have been sold. Also, many people are buying cars to use on the one day they cannot use their regular vehicle."

The Second Car

The arithmetic was available to anyone who owned a car. A household with two vehicles whose plates ended in different digits could drive every day of the week. By March 1993 the scientist Germán Piña Villalpando was describing the programme to an environmental conference as a "palliative that isn't solving the problem." "The Day Without a Car program stopped the contamination in the first year, but now it's ineffective because of the increase in the number of cars overall," he said.

Gunnar Eskeland, an economist at the World Bank, put it in a bank report: the policy "may actually have backfired, as many households responded by buying an additional car." Fernando Menéndez García, director of Mexico City's anti-pollution programme, said there were no plans to end it. "I've asked for the data that supports his conclusions," he told the Monitor. "Our figures show the growth of vehicle sales in Mexico City parallels sales growth nationwide." The city had in any case added a second line of defence: since December 1992, every vehicle had to pass two exhaust inspections a year. Environmentalists noted that verification was only as effective as the operator.

The Paper

In 2008 the Journal of Political Economy published "The Effect of Driving Restrictions on Air Quality in Mexico City," by Lucas W. Davis, then at the University of Michigan. Davis took hourly readings from the city's monitoring network for carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide, ozone, nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxide, and compared the years before and after November 1989. His conclusion was that "across pollutants and specifications there is no evidence that the restrictions have improved air quality." In the window immediately around the ban, every coefficient pointed the wrong way. Taken literally, Davis wrote, the estimate for carbon monoxide implied a 30 percent increase. Pollution rose at weekends and late at night relative to weekdays, when the ban was not in force. Subway and bus ridership showed no increase. Gasoline sales did not fall.

What rose was the number of cars. Davis estimated that registered vehicles in the metropolitan area increased by about 325,000 when the programme came in. New car sales rose too, but not by nearly enough to account for that, so the extra vehicles "must be composed overwhelmingly of used vehicles, imported from other parts of Mexico or from the much larger U.S. market." Older cars lacked emissions controls, and Mexico City drivers of the period, the paper noted, commonly tuned their engines for peak power. The city also had 75,000 taxis in 1989, roughly one for every 100 residents, against one for every 600 in New York, older on average than private cars and many of them Volkswagen Beetles. A 1992 Beetle emitted about four times as much carbon monoxide as a 1992 Golf.

Davis put the cost of the extra cars at more than $300 million a year, or $2.50 for each day each vehicle was kept off the road, and found no evidence of any benefit. "Drivers everywhere have a revealed preference for fast and convenient transportation," he wrote, "and will find ways to circumvent rationing programs of this form." By then the programme had been copied in Santiago, São Paulo and Bogotá.

The Saturday

On 5 July 2008 Mexico City extended the ban to Saturdays, one per month for affected cars, citing a steady rise in Saturday pollution. An analysis done beforehand predicted that the expansion would cut Saturday vehicle emissions of carbon monoxide by 17 percent and of nitrogen oxides and large particulates by 16 percent. Davis, now at the University of California, Berkeley, measured the result in Scientific Reports in 2017: "Across eight major pollutants, the program expansion had virtually no discernible effect on air quality." To check whether people had simply stayed at home, he examined Saturday attendance at the Mexico City Zoo and the National Anthropology Museum and the number of cars parked at the international airport. None of them fell.

A separate study by Francisco Gallego, Juan-Pablo Montero and Christian Salas, published in the Journal of Public Economics in 2013, used carbon monoxide records to reach a similar verdict on the original ban: household responses had been "ultimately unfortunate—more cars on the road and higher pollution levels."

The Hologram

The programme survived by changing who it applied to. Cars that passed the twice-yearly verificación received a hologram sticker, and the stickers marked "0" and "00" exempted a car from Hoy No Circula altogether. From 1997, according to an analysis in The Conversation, cars made in the previous eight years were exempt as long as they passed the emissions test. The ban now fell mainly on older cars, the kind Davis found people had bought to get around it. In 2014 the city tightened the rule so that cars past a certain age could no longer get the "0" whatever their test result.

Owners of older cars went to court. On 2 July 2015 the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation, resolving contradicción de tesis 88/2015, held that denying a car the "0" because of its age violated the constitutional right to equality, and that judges could let owners of 2007-and-earlier models obtain one through an amparo if their car passed the test. The head of the Comisión Ambiental de la Megalópolis said the next day that the Saturday restrictions would continue regardless. In March 2016 the valley recorded its first Phase 1 ozone emergency since 2005. Officials and environmentalists blamed the ruling, which was said to have put an extra 1.4 million vehicles back on the road each day. On 17 March the court issued a statement explaining that its decision had been made to protect the principle of equality and had never been meant to allow indiscriminate circulation. It added that the benefit applied only to those who filed for an amparo.

On 30 March the commission's coordinator, Martín Gutiérrez, announced that from 5 April to 30 June every car would be banned one weekday and one Saturday a month, hologram or not, taking about a million vehicles a day off the road. The Associated Press reported that cars were supposed to be checked every six months, "though it's common knowledge that for a bribe of US$20 or so drivers can ensure a car comes out 'clean.'" The federal environment secretary, Rafael Pacchiano, tweeted that "the definitive 'no circulation' program will align with the new rule for vehicular verification that will be presented soon." On 1 July 2016 the emergency measures ended, and cars with "0" and "00" stickers went back to driving every day, Saturdays included.

In 1989 Hoy No Circula took 20 percent of the city's vehicles off the road each weekday. Thirty years later, according to figures from the city's environment ministry reported by Reforma, it kept 258,000 of 4.1 million vehicles at home on a given weekday, about 6 percent. Sixty-eight percent of the fleet was new enough to pass the test and carry a "0" or "00", which allowed it to drive every day, pollution emergencies included. The programme is still in force.


Filed from public reporting:

Read more

Disney's Guest Assistance Card Gave Guests Who Could Not Wait in Line Faster Access With No Proof of Disability Required. Its Replacement Now Requires a Video Interview, and Disney's Own Court Papers Put Holders at 20 Percent of Guests.

Disney's Guest Assistance Card Gave Guests Who Could Not Wait in Line Faster Access With No Proof of Disability Required. Its Replacement Now Requires a Video Interview, and Disney's Own Court Papers Put Holders at 20 Percent of Guests.

Disney's Guest Assistance Card was, in Disney's later description, an accommodation that asked for nothing. A guest who could not wait in a conventional queue went to Guest Relations, said so, and received a card that opened a side entrance or a shorter line. NBC reported

By The Complaints Department
Westvleteren Abbey Sells Its Trappist Beer Only to Private Buyers Who Agree Not to Resell It. A Dutch Supermarket Put 7,200 Bottles on Its Shelves at 9.95 Euros Each Anyway.

Westvleteren Abbey Sells Its Trappist Beer Only to Private Buyers Who Agree Not to Resell It. A Dutch Supermarket Put 7,200 Bottles on Its Shelves at 9.95 Euros Each Anyway.

The Sint-Sixtus Abbey in Westvleteren, West Flanders, brews three Trappist beers and sells them to one kind of customer: the private individual. The abbey's own conditions of sale, which every buyer accepts, contain a clause of a single sentence, in which the buyer undertakes not to resell

By The Complaints Department
Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.

Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.

Michigan voters approved a bottle deposit by ballot in 1976. At 10 cents a container it became the highest refund in the country, and the neighbouring state of Indiana has no deposit at all. The arrangement is a standing invitation, and the Associated Press reported in 2013 that smugglers were

By The Complaints Department
US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.

US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.

The Department of Transportation added a provision dedicated to service animals on aircraft in 2008, codifying earlier guidance. Emotional support animals and psychiatric service animals counted as service animals, and airlines may not charge for service animals. Airlines were in turn allowed to require a letter from a licensed mental

By The Complaints Department