New York Replaced Its Payphones in 2016 With Free Sidewalk Kiosks That Let Anyone Browse the Web. Seven Months Later the Browsers Were Switched Off, Because People Were Using Them for Hours.
On 18 February 2016, Mayor Bill de Blasio stood at the corner of Third Avenue and 16th Street in Manhattan and made the first phone call from New York City's first LinkNYC kiosk. The kiosks were replacing the city's payphones, and each one offered free Wi-Fi, free domestic calls, USB charging ports, an emergency button and a built-in tablet for browsing the web. "You won't need to insert a quarter or any kind of money whatsoever," de Blasio said. "It will be the biggest and fastest network in the world, and completely free of charge. And one thing I know about my fellow New Yorkers, they like things that are free of charge."
The kiosks were to cost the taxpayer nothing. Under a franchise agreement signed in 2014, a consortium called CityBridge, made up of Intersection, Qualcomm and CIVIQ Smartscapes, would install at least 7,500 of them across the five boroughs and pay for everything through the advertising on their 55-inch screens. Intersection had been launched by Sidewalk Labs, a subsidiary of Alphabet, Google's parent company. The city was promised $500 million in guaranteed revenue over the first 12 years. The tablet, like the Wi-Fi, was there to help bridge the digital divide. Access to the internet, the city said, was no longer a luxury but a necessity.
The Buckets
By the summer, some of the people the tablets were meant for had found them. On Eighth Avenue in Chelsea, DNAinfo reported on 30 August, users at several kiosks had propped up overturned newspaper boxes and upside-down buckets in front of the screens to use as chairs. One user sat on a bucket near West 21st Street for hours, listening to music and browsing the web. A Chelsea resident of more than three decades, Simone Weissman, saw the problem in the specification: "The ability to play videos and movies — why do we need that in the street?"
Councilman Corey Johnson, whose district covers Chelsea and Hell's Kitchen, wrote to the city's Department of Information Technology and Telecommunications. "These kiosks are often monopolized by individuals creating personal spaces for themselves, engaging in activities that include playing loud explicit music, consuming drugs and alcohol, and the viewing of pornography," his letter said. He added that he had personally observed people watching pornography on the screens in view of nearby children. Community Board 4 had sent its own letter at the start of August, proposing time limits, lower volume and restricting the tablets to functions like 311, 911 and directions. Ernest Modarelli, co-chair of its transportation committee, put the design flaw precisely. "The real problem is not what they're watching," he said. "It's that we've given them an entertainment system with unlimited access to the internet."
Not everyone was troubled. Michael Lalime, a 35-year-old charging his phone before the first day of a new job, noted that the Eighth Avenue kiosks stood near adult stores such as Rainbow Station and The Blue Store. "Come on, Chelsea," he said. "Don't look if it's bothering you."
The Browser
On 14 September 2016, LinkNYC announced that it would remove web browsing from the tablets. The announcement came two days after a 41-year-old homeless man was arrested in Murray Hill for using a kiosk for what NY1 called self-pleasure. "Some users have been monopolizing the Link tablets and using them inappropriately, preventing others from being able to use them while frustrating the residents and businesses around them," CityBridge said. "The kiosks were never intended for anyone's extended, personal use and we want to ensure that Links are accessible and a welcome addition to New York City neighborhoods." A filtering system had been supposed to block inappropriate content. Time limits would be explored.
City Hall presented the change as an improvement. "The Mayor is addressing these quality-of-life complaints head on," a mayoral spokesman said. "Removing the internet browser from LinkNYC tablets will not affect the other great services LinkNYC provides." Johnson thanked the department on Twitter. Ruben Diaz, the Bronx borough president, who had celebrated the arrival of the kiosks in his borough earlier that month, called it "a step in the right direction," and warned that "a handful of less-than-wholesome users" must not "threaten the success of the entire enterprise." According to the city, 400 Links had by then been used more than 21 million times by nearly 475,000 people.
The Wi-Fi, the phone calls and the charging stayed. So did the screens on the other side of the kiosk, which showed advertising. By 2019, Gotham Gazette was describing tablet browsing as "an original feature of the kiosks."
The Cameras
The tablet browsing had not been the only thing on the kiosks to draw a letter. In March 2016, a month after launch, the New York Civil Liberties Union wrote to the mayor's office about CityBridge's privacy policy. To register, users had to give an email address and agree to CityBridge collecting information about the websites they visited on their own devices, how long they lingered and what they clicked. The company promised only "reasonable efforts" to clear out personally identifiable data, and only after 12 months of inactivity. "New Yorkers' private online activities shouldn't be used to create a massive database that's within the ready grasp of the NYPD," said Donna Lieberman, the NYCLU's executive director. The group also asked whether the kiosks' sensors and cameras fed into the NYPD's Domain Awareness System.
In April 2019 the NYPD arrested a man for smashing 42 kiosks, a spree recorded by the kiosks' own cameras, which Gotham Gazette judged most New Yorkers had not known were there. LinkNYC replied to users on Twitter that video was deleted after seven days and shared only in response to "valid subpoenas." The city said it would conduct a privacy audit of CityBridge.
The Franchise Fees
The advertising was not paying for itself either. Gotham Gazette, using city budget documents, calculated in May 2019 that Link revenue had fallen more than $21 million short of the guaranteed amounts since 2015, with a further $13 million shortfall projected. Intersection declined to share its advertising rate card, then denied that one existed. It also said it did not track how many paid campaigns had run.
On 3 March 2020, Jessica Tisch, the city's new technology commissioner, told the City Council that CityBridge had paid $2.6 million of the $32.3 million it owed for fiscal year 2019, and none of the $43.7 million owed for the current year. Over the previous 18 months, she said, it had reported $105 million in advertising revenue. It had installed 1,816 of the 2,353 kiosks due by July 2019, and none at all since the autumn of 2018. Most of the 537 missing kiosks were meant for neighbourhoods outside Manhattan. "New Yorkers who would benefit most from this service are not getting it," Tisch said. The consortium, she said, was "crying poverty." "I have no patience for it." THE CITY reported that officials were considering terminating the contract. Robert Holden, chair of the Council's technology committee, said New Yorkers were being shortchanged. CityBridge called the testimony "a fictional narrative that ignores the City's responsibility for the current state of affairs," and blamed "the city's own rules and bureaucracy."
The state comptroller, Thomas DiNapoli, audited the programme in 2021. CityBridge had been due to install 3,153 kiosks by 20 July 2020 and had built 1,869. The Bronx, where city officials estimated 38 per cent of households lacked high-speed internet, had 137, less than half the number in the Manhattan ZIP code containing Times Square. CityBridge was $68.93 million behind on payments, including interest. Of 227 locations inspected, 76 per cent had "cleanliness and/or operation issues, including dirty/grimy tablet screens." The city did not terminate the contract. It renegotiated it in June 2021, and according to a later City Council account, the 50 per cent revenue share became a minimum of $3 million a year plus 8 per cent of gross revenue above $100 million.
The Towers
The renegotiated programme had a new centrepiece: the Link5G tower, a 32-foot pole designed to hold the equipment of up to five mobile carriers and expected to serve the city for a decade. At a Council hearing on 7 June 2023, more than 100 people testified for and against it, and the Council's summary recorded that no telecommunications company was yet using the towers and that CityBridge could not say what it would charge carriers who did. The Federal Communications Commission had written to CityBridge in April ordering a pause on installations for historic preservation and environmental review. The city's Office of Technology and Innovation deferred many questions to CityBridge, and its officials authorised to speak on the record left before CityBridge testified.
In October 2026, ten years after the launch, Michael Samuelian, director of Urban Tech at Cornell Tech, published an essay in Vital City headlined "Let's Be Honest. LinkNYC Has Been a Failure." He described the towers as "an escalation of the same mistake."
In September 2016, the tablets were switched off because the kiosks were "never intended for anyone's extended, personal use." The people who had used them for hours had been sitting on buckets. CityBridge held a 15-year franchise on the sidewalk, and in the 18 months before March 2020 reported $105 million in advertising from it, while paying the city none of the $43.7 million it owed for the fiscal year.
Filed from public reporting:
- CBS New York — "De Blasio Launches Free Wi-Fi, Charging Stations Throughout City"
- New York Civil Liberties Union — "NYCLU: City's Public Wi-Fi Raises Privacy Concerns"
- DNAinfo — "LinkNYC Users Watching Porn, Doing Drugs on Chelsea Sidewalks, Locals Say"
- NY1 — "LinkNYC Ends Web Browsing at Kiosks After Months of Complaints About Public Lewdness and Homeless Encampments"
- ABC7 New York — "City pulls plug on internet browser in LinkNYC tablets after porn complaints"
- TechCrunch — "NYC public internet kiosk tablets have been disabled, because people obviously used them for porn"
- Gotham Gazette — "Payphone-Replacing LinkNYC Kiosks Not Generating Projected Revenue"
- THE CITY via amNewYork — "City Hall may pull plug on LinkNYC owner over missing kiosks — and $75M owed"
- Smart Cities Dive — "NYC tech official slams LinkNYC group for contract negligence: 'CityBridge is delinquent'"
- City & State — "DoITT head Jessica Tisch's hard line against LinkNYC vendor"
- StateScoop — "New York prepares for 5G kiosks after stinging program review"
- New York City Council — "LinkNYC 5G Tower Hearing Finds Limited City Oversight of Program Administration, Demonstrates Need For Better Processes"
- Vital City — "Let's Be Honest. LinkNYC Has Been a Failure."