Seattle Spent $5 Million on Five Self-Cleaning Public Toilets in 2004. Four Years Later It Sold All Five on eBay to a Racetrack Owner for $12,549.
Seattle argued about public toilets for years before it bought any. In 2001 the City Council authorised five automated, self-cleaning units as an alternative to portable toilets, and when Mayor Paul Schell vetoed the plan, the council overrode him. Councilman Nick Licata said the toilets would "be beneficial to local businesses because tourists, shoppers, residents, and the homeless are equally accommodated." Jean Godden, then a Seattle Times columnist, wrote in support: "It's time to do… the humane thing." Richard McIver cast the lone vote against in the budget committee. Some people warned at the time that the stalls would become havens for illicit use. Seattle Public Utilities said the community would make sure that did not happen.
The toilets went into service in early 2004 at Victor Steinbrueck Park beside Pike Place Market, at Waterfront Park, in Occidental Park in Pioneer Square, in Hing Hay Park in the International District and at 1801 Broadway on Capitol Hill. They were German-made, round and silver, nine feet high and twelve feet around. The doors slid open like a lift's. A female voice welcomed users in English and Spanish and explained what to do. After each visit the toilet flushed two or three times, the seat retracted to be pressure-washed and dried, and the sloped floor was scrubbed and drained. There was an emergency button that dialled 911. Use was free.
The Arrangement
In the usual arrangement for an American city that wants automated toilets, The New York Times explained, an outdoor advertising company such as JCDecaux supplies and maintains the units in exchange for the right to sell ads on bus shelters and kiosks. Seattle's strict advertising law ruled that out, so JCDecaux and Cemusa declined to bid. The maintenance contract went to Northwest Cascade, a local company with no prior experience in the field. The bill went to the sewer ratepayers, through a tax on wastewater rates that cost the average household about $2.59 a year.
The city's own figures were not flattering. A Seattle Public Utilities report to the council put the cost of leasing and maintaining each toilet at $360 a day, against $16 a day for a portable toilet. The Seattle Times described the whole programme as a $6.6 million project; the figure most often given for the toilets themselves was $5 million, or $1 million apiece over five years.
The Floor
The self-cleaning floor was the first feature to go. Dirt tracked in from the street turned to mud, and paper turned to sludge, so the city switched the floor scrubbers off and had crews mop twice a day instead. "It just got to the point where we were just wasting water," said Sandy Kraus, the utility's project manager. The contract price was not reduced. The city also cut the time before the doors opened automatically from 15 minutes to 10, lit the sites and locked most of them at night.
The privacy that made the stalls pleasant to use made them pleasant for other purposes. Between June 2006 and June 2007, Seattle police logged more than 3,300 service calls for the five locations, for everything from narcotics to weapons, although the West Precinct captain said the areas had the same problems with or without toilets in them. Luigi Gephart, who was homeless and used the Occidental Park unit, called it "the revolving crack house" and advised tourists to stay away. A homeless woman named Veronyka Cordner told The New York Times, "I'm not going to lie: I used to smoke crack in there," before adding that she would no longer go inside. The Downtown Seattle Association found that people were relieving themselves in the street about 30 percent more often than before the toilets arrived.
The busiest unit, at Steinbrueck Park, could serve at most about 195 people in a 13-hour day and cost nearly $130,000 to run in 2007. The 23 stalls and urinals in the two Pike Place Market restrooms nearby could serve 11,903 in an 11.5-hour day and cost $200,000. Each automated cycle used 3.6 to 7.6 gallons of water. A visitor to the market toilets used about 1.7, including washing their hands.
The Report
On Monday 24 March 2008 Seattle Public Utilities recommended cancelling the contract. Its report found the toilets had been well used both as intended and as a refuge for drug use and dealing, drinking and prostitution, and that some homeless people now avoided them because of it. Councilmember Sally Clark held a news conference in Hing Hay Park and called the programme an "expensive experiment." "They give people a place to hide out, to duck out of public sight," she said. McIver, seven years after his dissent, had a shorter statement. "I was right," he said.
On 19 May the council voted to remove the toilets early, agreeing to pay a $540,000 fee to end the contract five years ahead of schedule. Licata, who had promised in 2001 that everyone would be equally accommodated, voted to end it. So did Godden, by then a council member. The Seattle Times editorial board, which had urged a flush for years, gave the council credit for finally listening and observed that a restroom requiring spoken instructions was "way more technology than the city needed." The doors closed on 1 August.
The Auction
The city listed all five toilets on eBay on the afternoon of Wednesday 16 July 2008, through its online auction agent, Bidadoo, with a minimum bid of $89,000 each. Andy Ryan, the utility's spokesman, told a Seattle Times columnist this was a deal. Nobody bid.
The second auction had no minimum. It drew more than 9,000 page views and 148 bids, and closed on the evening of Thursday 14 August. All five lots went to Racecar Supply of Rochester, Washington, for between $1,625 and $4,899 apiece, a total of $12,549. After Bidadoo's 17 percent commission the city expected to recover about $10,400 for its utility fund. "What a buy," said the company's owner, Butch Behn, who also owned the South Sound Speedway. "Wouldn't you think it's a really good deal, considering what they paid for them? It was a gift." He planned to install two at the track, sell the others and perhaps keep one for parts.
The city took the result calmly. "We sold them for what the market determined them to be worth," Ryan said. "Did we get hosed? I'm not sure." Pat Miller, the city's surplus manager, said the loss had been in maintaining them for years, not in selling them. "We're just thrilled that we don't have them anymore," he said. He told the Associated Press that cities periodically have unusual things to get rid of, and recalled the 66-foot topiary dinosaurs outside Seattle Center, which had been rumoured to interest Michael Jackson. A year later Behn told KING 5: "We really didn't buy them. We stole them."
The Louvres
Portland was watching. The day after Seattle put its toilets on eBay, The New York Times reported that Randy Leonard, a Portland city commissioner, had helped design a prototype that would cost $50,000 against some $300,000 for an automated unit, with open gaps at the top and bottom to discourage drug use and prostitution. "We in the U.S. have yet to shed our puritanical roots," he said. "We are uptight about toilets." Anna DiBenedetto, a staff assistant in Leonard's office, was later blunter. "We really looked at Seattle as what not to do," she said. "We think it was the design that was the fatal flaw. Trying to be comfortable and private makes people feel more empowered to do the illegal activities that people do in public toilets."
The Portland Loo, patented in 2010, is the Seattle toilet with every comfort removed. It is heavy-gauge stainless steel painted an uninviting "Portland Gray," with a "prison grade" bowl, a concrete floor and angled steel louvres at top and bottom so that passers-by and police can see how many people are inside. There is no mirror to smash. The only tap is outside, so nobody can wash clothes in it. The interior light is blue, which makes veins hard to find. "It's not supposed to be a comfortable place," its sales manager, Evan Madden, told The Seattle Times. San Francisco kept its 25 automated toilets, which officials there said required constant fiddling. "You need a dedicated crew taking care of them every day," said J. François Nion of JCDecaux North America.
Seattle came round. It installed two Portland Loos at the Rainier Beach Playfield, and in 2019 spent $550,000 on one more, with installation, at the Ballard Commons. Behn's toilets were still on his property eleven years after the auction. Moving them had cost him another $30,000, and when he tried to install one, the county told him it was too close to a well house. He had no regrets. "I got more publicity out of those toilets than anything you could ever do in your life," he said.
Filed from public reporting:
- Seattle Post-Intelligencer (reposted) — "Cancel toilet contract, city told"
- The Seattle Times — "Were high-tech toilets worth $6.6 million?"
- The Seattle Times — "Seattle Public Utilities' report recommends getting rid of self-cleaning toilets"
- The Stranger — "In the Hall"
- The Seattle Times — "Fleeced and flushed: the public toilet fiasco"
- The New York Times — "Seattle's Automated Toilets Go Way of the Box and Chain"
- Associated Press via NBC News — "Seattle selling five troublesome toilets on eBay"
- The Seattle Times — "Seattle's $5 million automated public toilets sold for $12,000"
- Associated Press via 6abc — "Seattle relieved to lose its high-tech toilets"
- KING 5 — "Seattle's million dollar toilets ready to flush again"
- The Seattle Times — "It's austere and uncomfortable. That's precisely the reason the 'Portland Loo' is finding a home in King County"