The FTC Wrote a Rule Requiring That Cancelling a Subscription Be as Easy as Starting One. A Federal Court Vacated It Six Days Before It Took Effect, Over a Missing Cost Analysis.

Share
The FTC Wrote a Rule Requiring That Cancelling a Subscription Be as Easy as Starting One. A Federal Court Vacated It Six Days Before It Took Effect, Over a Missing Cost Analysis.
Photo by Markus Winkler / Unsplash

The Federal Trade Commission finalised its revised Negative Option Rule in October 2024. It was known almost immediately as the click-to-cancel rule, because its central requirement was that a subscription be as easy to leave as it was to join. If a customer could sign up in four clicks on a website, the company could not require a telephone call, a retention conversation, or a visit to a branch to get out.

The rule also required that the terms of a recurring charge be disclosed before checkout rather than after, and that the customer affirmatively consent to them. It was scheduled to take effect on 14 July 2025.

Six Days

On 8 July 2025, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit vacated the rule in its entirety, in Custom Communications, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission. The compliance deadline was six days away. Companies that had rebuilt their cancellation flows had done so for a requirement that no longer existed.

The court did not rule that the requirements were unlawful, unreasonable, or beyond the commission's authority to impose. It did not address the substance at all.

The Analysis That Was Not Performed

Section 22 of the FTC Act requires the commission to publish a preliminary regulatory analysis when a proposed rule will impose compliance costs above $100 million. The commission concluded that this rule would exceed that threshold. It did not publish the preliminary analysis. It published a final one instead, and argued the omission was harmless.

The Eighth Circuit disagreed, holding that the step is mandatory and that skipping it deprived affected businesses of the opportunity to comment on the cost estimate before the rule was fixed. The rule was vacated on that basis alone.

The finding is entirely procedural and entirely correct. Agencies that write rules are bound by the rules about writing rules, and an agency permitted to skip inconvenient steps when it is confident of the outcome is a worse agency than one that is not. This is a real principle and it is not diminished by what it produced here.

What the Threshold Implies

The analysis was triggered because the commission determined that compliance would cost the affected industries more than $100 million.

Compliance meant letting customers cancel online. The figure is therefore an estimate, produced for regulatory purposes, of what American businesses stand to lose by making it as easy to stop paying as to start. It is not a hardware cost; the cancel button is not expensive to build. It is the value of the friction.

That estimate is what obliged the commission to perform an additional round of analysis, and the failure to perform that analysis is what killed the rule. The friction was substantial enough to require the paperwork, and the paperwork was what the rule died of.

Under Review

The commission has restarted. On 30 January 2026 it submitted a draft advance notice of proposed rulemaking on negative option plans to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, which is the first formal step of a process that produced a rule once already and took several years to do it.

Nothing prevents the commission from arriving at the same requirements a second time, provided it publishes the preliminary analysis. In the interim, the governing standard is the one that applied before October 2024, and the cancellation flow is whatever the company has decided it should be.


Filed from public reporting:

Read more

Disney's Guest Assistance Card Gave Guests Who Could Not Wait in Line Faster Access With No Proof of Disability Required. Its Replacement Now Requires a Video Interview, and Disney's Own Court Papers Put Holders at 20 Percent of Guests.

Disney's Guest Assistance Card Gave Guests Who Could Not Wait in Line Faster Access With No Proof of Disability Required. Its Replacement Now Requires a Video Interview, and Disney's Own Court Papers Put Holders at 20 Percent of Guests.

Disney's Guest Assistance Card was, in Disney's later description, an accommodation that asked for nothing. A guest who could not wait in a conventional queue went to Guest Relations, said so, and received a card that opened a side entrance or a shorter line. NBC reported

By The Complaints Department
Westvleteren Abbey Sells Its Trappist Beer Only to Private Buyers Who Agree Not to Resell It. A Dutch Supermarket Put 7,200 Bottles on Its Shelves at 9.95 Euros Each Anyway.

Westvleteren Abbey Sells Its Trappist Beer Only to Private Buyers Who Agree Not to Resell It. A Dutch Supermarket Put 7,200 Bottles on Its Shelves at 9.95 Euros Each Anyway.

The Sint-Sixtus Abbey in Westvleteren, West Flanders, brews three Trappist beers and sells them to one kind of customer: the private individual. The abbey's own conditions of sale, which every buyer accepts, contain a clause of a single sentence, in which the buyer undertakes not to resell

By The Complaints Department
Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.

Michigan Refunds 10 Cents a Can, a Trade a 1996 Seinfeld Episode Explained to the Nation. Its Attorney General Said a Flint Man Returned Tens of Thousands From Indiana, and He Was Ordered to Repay $400,000, Which at a Dime Apiece Is Four Million Cans.

Michigan voters approved a bottle deposit by ballot in 1976. At 10 cents a container it became the highest refund in the country, and the neighbouring state of Indiana has no deposit at all. The arrangement is a standing invitation, and the Associated Press reported in 2013 that smugglers were

By The Complaints Department
US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.

US Airlines Let Emotional Support Animals Fly Free on a Mental Health Professional's Letter. Delta Was Carrying Nearly 250,000 Service and Support Animals a Year by 2018, and the Government Abolished the Category in 2020.

The Department of Transportation added a provision dedicated to service animals on aircraft in 2008, codifying earlier guidance. Emotional support animals and psychiatric service animals counted as service animals, and airlines may not charge for service animals. Airlines were in turn allowed to require a letter from a licensed mental

By The Complaints Department