In 2011 Greece's Deputy Health Minister Observed That 2 Percent of Zakynthos Appeared to Be Blind. When the Social Insurance Fund Re-Examined 221 Recipients the Next Year, 182 Turned Out Not to Be.
In 2011 a Greek deputy health minister, Markos Bolaris, observed that 2 percent of the residents of Zakynthos appeared to be blind. Iefimerida reported the remark in August 2012. The Ionian island has a population of 35,000 to 39,000, depending on whether one asks the Telegraph or the Wall Street Journal, and the Wall Street Journal cited a 2004 study in a WHO journal to the effect that the usual European rate is about a ninth of that. The benefit for the blind was at least 350 euros a month, more with age and family status, more again for anyone supposedly in need of a carer.
The Christian Science Monitor reported in April 2012 that the "blind" of Zakynthos had been seen driving taxis, hunting, running shops and taverns, and farming. The island was by then being called "the island of the blind", a name that John Venardos, a hotelier who is genuinely blind, quoted back with distaste: "They are calling us 'the island of the blind.'" The Monitor also reported that the scandal reportedly surfaced when a welfare office employee watched an islander take off dark glasses and drive away in a Porsche. What followed was a Greek benefit scandal, a Greek benefit audit and a Greek court case, and the court case is still the slowest of the three.
The Numbers
The figures vary by speaker. Mayor Stelios Bozikis told the Telegraph: "Out of 650 registered blind people on the island, we estimate that at least 600 are fraudulent claims." That is an estimate by the man who filed the complaint. The Wall Street Journal, citing the health ministry, put the recipients at nearly 700 and reported that only 190 of them had taken part in a nationwide registration of disability claimants. About 100 islanders went to an Athens hospital for eye tests, of whom the ministry said about 40 proved legally blind. A person close to the situation put it at slightly more than 50. Keep Talking Greece, citing the Health Ministry's census, gave 689 beneficiaries in 2011, of whom 100 appeared before health committees and 60 were found not to be blind.
The best-documented count is the re-examination run by IKA-ETAM, the social insurance fund, announced on 17 September 2012 and summarised by News247. It called 388 people. A total of 146 did not show up and 21 examinations were postponed. Of the 221 examined, 39 were blind, 34 of them for life and 5 for one year, and 182 were not. News247 also quotes Ethnos from August 2012: 616 called, 318 attended, 100 found entitled. The two counts do not match and neither source explains why.
The Signatures
Iefimerida put blindness recipients at over 600 of 1,300 disability beneficiaries in the island's welfare programme. A blindness benefit needed a certificate from a state hospital ophthalmologist and a decision signed by the prefecture. News247 reports that most certificates were issued on the opinion of one ophthalmologist, Nikolaos Vartzelis, then director of ophthalmology at the Zakynthos hospital. The prefect from 1998 to 2010, Dionysis Gasparos, signed them.
According to Iefimerida, the prefecture's own welfare department noticed the rise in beneficiaries in 2001. Its head began asking in writing for re-checks in 2003, and the requests continued in 2005 while the prefect kept signing. In 2006 health inspectors came after a resident complained, performed no real check, and left empty-handed. In 2008 a committee of one ophthalmologist and one substitute was formed to examine the beneficiaries; both doctors resigned for unknown reasons and the matter stopped. News247 adds that the welfare service flagged the rise from 2001 and that the prefect at the time kept signing.
A 2015 column in To Vima by Lori Keza remarked that no one on Zakynthos noticed the blind going to collect the benefit in cars. A Lifo columnist, Aris Dimokidis, wrote in March 2012 of a doctor who had certified one man as blind and, for his driving licence, as seeing well, and of a taxi driver on the disability allowance.
Both men denied wrongdoing. Vartzelis resigned in late March 2012 and, the Journal reported, denied making false diagnoses or taking money: "We were lenient, but within the limits of the law." Gasparos told the Journal: "I am not the one who puts you down as blind." The Telegraph and the Monitor described an allegation that bribes and votes were exchanged for registrations; the Monitor reports both men denied the charges.
The Courts
The Zakynthos prosecutor ordered an investigation in 2011. The investigation closed in October 2014, when Radio1d reported that Gasparos and the retired hospital ophthalmologist were charged with fraud against the state, committed jointly, professionally, habitually and continuously, of more than 120,000 euros, the doctor also with issuing false certificates. Both were banned from leaving the country. Separately, the prosecutor charged dozens of recipients with misdemeanour fraud for taking the benefit without meeting the legal requirements. News247 reported in May 2015 that their trials had begun in January, that some faced up to five years, and that some had won.
The felony trial opened in Patras on 22 November 2019. Thebest.gr reported that the complaint had cited at least 800 allowances and that the indictment halved this. The court found both defendants guilty of false certification and fraud and imposed nine years' imprisonment on each, then reduced the sentence after accepting mitigating factors, without the paper giving the reduced figure. Of the 341 allowances in the indictment, it held that 51 had been validly granted on the findings of second-instance health committees. Both men were released pending appeal on condition of reporting to a police station on the first five days of each month. The prosecutor, as the paper reported it, described an operation that issued allowances, possibly for political reasons, in which the doctor certified and the official decided.
On 4 October 2021 the five-member felony appeals court in Patras unanimously acquitted Gasparos, following the recommendation of the prosecutor on the bench, according to Ta Nea and CNN Greece. His lawyer, Alexis Kougias, said the defence had shown the charge was completely fabricated by local political rivals, naming the former mayor Bozikis. That is the defence's statement. The 2021 reports do not mention the ophthalmologist, and the result of his appeal does not appear in the reporting.
The Audit
The wider context was the one Greece's creditors were watching. The Monitor reported in April 2012 that the Labor ministry had halted welfare or pension payments to 200,000 people, about 2 percent of the population, the week before, and cited pensions paid for long-dead relatives and maternity benefits for women with no children. Fraudulent claims, it said, had cost 111 million euros the previous year.
The remedy was a census: every disability beneficiary was required to turn up. Keep Talking Greece reported on 19 March 2012 that 240,292 people had been beneficiaries in 2011 and 203,998 took part. The Health Minister, Andreas Loverdos, said the 37,000 who did not either stayed away or lacked proper documents. Protothema reported that the ministry prepared a list of 36,000 and that its depleted legal department could not cope with recovering money from them, so it was considering hiring private lawyers on commission.
The genuine recipients were then asked to appear before health committees to verify their disability percentage. Keep Talking Greece reported that real beneficiaries, already retested every five years, would be retested at shorter intervals, and that the new committee system was working badly, with waits of more than six months. Yannis Vardakastanis, president of the National Confederation of Disabled People, told the Journal that the portrayal of disabled people in the media had been "absolutely unbearable". No count of genuine claimants who lost payments appears in the reporting.
Bolaris told the Journal: "If it didn't matter to some before, for us today, it must matter." The prefecture's welfare department had first asked in writing in 2003. The convictions came in 2019, and the man who signed the decisions was acquitted two years later.
Filed from public reporting:
- Christian Science Monitor — "Greek 'island of the blind'? More like 'island of welfare cheats'"
- Wall Street Journal (repost on Ellinika Themata) — "'Island of the Blind' Riles a Greek Public Facing Cutbacks"
- Telegraph via Gulf News — "'Island of the Blind' sheds light on level of corruption"
- Keep Talking Greece — "Fake Social Benefits: Greek 'Party' Worth €111 Million"
- Protothema — "More fake benefits emerge after those for the blind"
- Iefimerida — "Πώς στήθηκε η κομπίνα με τους τυφλούς στη Ζάκυνθο"
- News247 — "Οι 'τυφλοί' της Ζακύνθου και η τυφλή ελληνική δικαιοσύνη"
- Radio1d — "Διώξεις για τα επιδόματα σε τυφλούς-μαϊμού στη Ζάκυνθο"
- TheBest.gr — "Οι 'τυφλοί' της Ζακύνθου και τα σωρηδόν επιδόματα στα δικαστήρια της Πάτρας"
- TheBest.gr — "Βαρύς ο πέλεκυς του δικαστηρίου της Πάτρας σε αιρετό και γιατρό από τη Ζάκυνθο για τα μαϊμού επιδόματα τυφλών"
- Ta Nea — "Αθώος ο πρώην νομάρχης Ζακύνθου για την υπόθεση με τα πλαστά επιδόματα τυφλότητας"
- CNN Greece — "Υπόθεση «τυφλών της Ζακύνθου»: Αθώος κρίθηκε ο πρώην νομάρχης"
- To Vima — "Παραδειγματισμός"
- Lifo — "Οι 'ξαφνικές' προεκλογικές αποκαλύψεις διαφθοράς"